The match between Atalanta and Juventus on 6 April 1960 is also the first time that the two teams face each other in the Coppa Italia. It would a game that would more than go the distance, and in similar fashion to this week's match in 2019, it was a straight knockout quarter-final.
The Bianconeri get off to a quick start with a goal from Severino Lojodice, despite the goalkeeper looking like he may have kept it out off the line. Juve score a second to head into half time two goals to the good, thanks to a stunning left-footed free-kick from Omar Sivori.
However, in the second half Atalanta manage to recover, with a goal by Rinaldo Olivieri and a penalty converted by a future Juventus coach, Rino Marchesi to send the game into extra-time.
The sides still cannot be separated so the game goes to penalty kicks. At the time both sides would nominate one player to take them all, and both Marchesi for Atalanta and Antonio Montico score their six penalties. Also, unlike in the modern era of sudden-death, the game would then be decided by a coin toss. Juventus captain, Umberto Colombo chose heads on the 100 lire coin flip and lady luck saw the Bianconeri advance to the semi-finals where they would beat Lazio.